About The Firm

I’ve built my career on the philosophy that everyone deserves a day in court. I treat every case as if it is going to trial. From our very first meeting, my experienced paralegal team and I work to collect evidence and prepare for anything the insurance companies and other large corporations might present. Our goal is to get your life back on track and to make you whole again after suffering through injury, abuse, or the wrongful death of a loved one. 

There Should Not Be A Barrier To Access Justice

I work on a contingency fee basis. What this means is that there is not a fee for my services unless I win your case. I defend the rights of Floridians from all walks of life and widen access to the civil justice system. My team is able to make a difference in the lives of victims of Personal Injury, Wrongful Death, and Sexual Abuse.

Clear Communication

I believe that clear and prompt communication is essential for positive outcomes. I personally meet with every client from the very beginning of our relationship. My staff and I promptly return all calls and emails. When you work with my firm, you receive the benefit of working directly with a small group of experienced professionals who care about your case and are driven to get you the maximum compensation possible.

I have been a resident of Brevard County since 1987. I graduated from Satellite High School in 2000 and received my undergraduate degree in philosophy from the University of Virginia in 2004. This course of study trained me to develop the critical thinking and logical analysis that I would later utilize when I began working on my law degree at the University of Florida. After law school, I had the opportunity to continue my education and earn a Masters of Law (LL.M.) at the University of Miami. This rigorous program honed my analytical abilities, gave me an appreciation for the importance of attention to detail, and gave me immense experience in analyzing complex statutes and case law. After completing my masters degree at the University of Miami, I was mentored by a federal prosecutor (Assistant United States Attorney) who invited me to watch one of his federal criminal jury trials. The pressure situation, the high stakes, and the competitive environment in the courtroom reminded me of my experience as a varsity swimmer at the University of Virginia. It was at that moment I realized that I was meant to be a trial attorney. 

I began my legal career as a prosecutor at the 18th Circuit State Attorney’s Office in Brevard County. I handled thousands of cases, ranging from simple misdemeanors to serious felonies. During my time as a prosecutor, I developed my love for jury trials. I also cultivated a deep appreciation for advocating on behalf of victims who had been wronged. However, even after a successful jury trial as a prosecutor, there was never any meaningful compensation for crime victims. I knew that when I entered private practice and represented victims in the civil justice system, I would have the opportunity to bring true justice to victims and to obtain compensation for them that would allow them to move on with their lives. The adversaries became big insurance companies and businesses whose purpose it is to protect their bottom lines, rather than assist the injured. 

I built my firm in Downtown Melbourne because my heart and soul are in Brevard County. The relationships I have in the community and within the legal profession have helped me to establish roots that will sustain me into the future. My firm has the strong support of very talented and experienced paralegals. We do our best to provide positive outcomes for our clients. We leave no stone unturned while investigating cases and are always ready to bring every case to trial if necessary.

What differentiates Andrew Pickett Law from many law firms that practice in the area of personal injury is that I have significant jury trial experience, and I am equipped to battle insurance companies and large corporations in the courtroom.  Over the last 10 years, I have tried to verdict over 50 jury trials.

I am committed to continually honing my trial skills, my presentation abilities, and my public speaking.  To that end, I have participated in several intensive trial seminars, including Gerry Spence’s Trial Lawyers College, which I graduated from in 2018.  This intensive 3-week program elevated my trial abilities and armed me with the trial skills that allowed me to obtain a verdict in the amount of $2.5 million against State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company in May of 2019.   I strive for continuous improvement of my trial abilities and dedicate significant time and resources to learn new skills and gain insights into the areas of cognitive science and psychology. 

Community Involvement

Present

• LEAD Brevard 4 Under 40 Award Recipient (2020)
• Immediate Past President of the Brevard County Bar Association
• Vice Chair of the 18th Circuit Judicial Nominating Commission
• Board of Directors of Circles of Care
• Board of Directors for Melbourne Main Street
• Part-Time Instructor at the Law Enforcement Academy at Eastern Florida State College
• Melbourne Regional Chamber of East Central Florida
• Florida Justice Association
• Central Florida Trial Lawyers Association
• Brevard County Civilian Military Council
• LEAD Brevard
• American Association for Justice
• The National Trial Lawyers

Past

• Florida Bar Young Lawyers Division Board of Governors (2012-2018)
• Adjunct Instructor in the Paralegal Program at Eastern Florida State College
• President of the Young Lawyers Division of the Brevard County Bar Association
• Graduate of Leadership Brevard (Class of 2012)
• Board of Directors for the Friends of the Children’s Advocacy 
• Board of Directors of the Space Coast Tiger Bay Club
• Grant Review Committee for the Community Foundation for Brevard
• Florida Supreme Court Justice Teaching Program
• Vassar B. Carlton American Inn of Court
• Volunteer Judge for 18th Circuit Teen Court Program

Awards

• Graduate of Gerry Spence’s Trial Lawyers College (2018)
• Graduate of the Christian J. Searcy Voir Dire Institute (2017)
• Graduate of the Al J. Cone Trial Advocacy Institute (2014)
• Top 12 Finalist for LEAD Brevard 4 Under 40 Award (2015 and 2019)
• “AV Preeminent®“ rating from the Martindale-Hubbell® Bar Register of Preeminent Lawyers (2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020)
• Selected as a Rising Star by Florida Super Lawyers Magazine (2016, 2017, 2018, 2019)
• Avvo.com Rating of 10.0/10.0 (“Superb”)
• Named one of Ten to Watch in 2013 by Florida Today newspaper
• 18th Circuit State Attorney’s Office Pride In Excellence Attorney of the Year Award (2011)
• Member of the Year Award by the Vassar B. Carlton American Inn of Court (2011)

Bar Admissions

• All Florida Courts
• United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida
• United States Supreme Court

Education

• University of Virginia, B.A. in Philosophy (2004)
• University of Florida, J.D. (2008)
• University of Miami, LL.M (2009)

About

Tiffany A. Whitehouse, Attorney and Registered Nurse

Tiffany Whitehouse is both an experienced attorney and a Registered Nurse. She uses her unique medical background and legal expertise to evaluate cases and create succinct arguments to ensure the best outcomes for our clients. Tiffany has lived in Brevard County for over 20 years and was the first student to graduate from Space Coast Jr./Sr. High School with both her high school diploma and her Associate’s Degree via the dual enrollment program in 2007. In 2016, Tiffany received a dean’s scholarship to attend law school at Florida A&M University College of Law. She earned her J.D. degree in 2018 and was awarded Magna Cum Laude honors. Following law school, Tiffany began her career as an Assistant Public Defender in the 18th Judicial Circuit in Brevard County, Florida. There, she refined her courtroom skills while handling cases ranging from misdemeanors to first-degree felonies. She transitioned from the criminal realm to personal injury in 2023 and gained extensive experience working for Morgan & Morgan, P.A. before finding her “home” at Andrew Pickett Law.

Tiffany Werner, Litigation Attorney

I have selected my team of talented paralegals to aid my practice and to work together with me on every single case. My paralegals are highly qualified and have extensive experience working in both the insurance industry and in civil litigation. Our philosophies align when it comes to bringing justice to victims of Personal Injury, Wrongful Death, and Sexual Abuse. We all work together to ensure that we understand our clients’ cases and that we can obtain the highest settlement possible, or take the case to trial if it is the right path for the client. When you work with Andrew Pickett Law, you will be working closely with all of us, and I can assure you, you are in good hands. 

Vonda Vassar, Pre-Suit Paralegal

Vonda Vassar is an excellent paralegal who brings more than 30 years of experience in insurance claims adjusting to our firm. Working in the industry for so long has provided her with valuable insights into how insurance companies work and how they can short-change victims who are unfamiliar with the system. Her expertise guides our discovery and investigation process. Her attention to detail and prompt communication helps assure our clients that their cases are being looked after by a dedicated team of professionals who care about their well-being and the outcome of their case.

Lauren Scarborough, Pre-Suit Assistant

Lauren, originally from Mississippi and recent resident of the Space Coast, serves as the first point of contact for clients, visitors, and callers. With a background in Theatre and tourism/hospitality management, she brings a warm, professional presence and a strong commitment to client service. Known for her organizational skills, attention to detail, and approachable demeanor, she helps create a positive and efficient environment for both clients and staff.

Lindsey Pike, Litigation Paralegal

Lindsey Pike is a dynamic and results-driven professional with a rich history in the legal field, an entrepreneurial spirit that has fueled her success across various industries, and a heart for community advocacy. A graduate of the University of Central Florida with a Bachelor of Science in Criminal Justice and a minor in Legal Studies, Lindsey has built an impressive career spanning roles such as Paralegal, Felony Trial Secretary, Real Estate Agent, and business owner. Her previous tenure at the Office of the State Attorney and other remarkable law firms exemplifies her ability to manage complex cases, conduct in-depth research, and implement efficient systems. Her skillful navigation of legal complexities and her natural ability to foster collaboration make her an invaluable member to the Andrew Pickett Law team.

Tatiana Hodgson, Litigation Paralegal

Tatiana brings over 20 years of legal experience to the firm, with a diverse background in plaintiff representation, insurance defense litigation, and criminal law. She holds a degree in Legal Studies from Broward College and is a Florida Registered Paralegal, a licensed notary, and fluent in both English and Spanish.

Driven by a deep passion for helping others, Tatiana is committed to providing compassionate, client-focused support. She values working with individuals from all walks of life and believes that strong teamwork and open communication lead to the best outcomes. Tatiana was drawn to Andrew Pickett Law for its commitment to compassion, excellence, and relentless advocacy—values that closely align with her own.

Arturo Zermeño, Medical Records Coordinator

Arturo Zermeño, born in December 1998 in Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico. He considers himself a person with a result-oriented approach, always looking for efficient and effective solutions, while being profoundly committed to ethics and respect for all parties involved. His passion for sports has allowed him to develop teamwork skills, discipline, and resilience, which he complements with his ability to adapt to challenges and maintain a positive attitude in complex situations.

About

Operations & Support Team

Jeremie Cooper, Firm Administrator

Jeremie is a native of Brevard County and a Florida Registered Paralegal. She holds a degree in Legal Studies from the University of Central Florida and brings over 20 years of legal experience to the firm. Jeremie brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise to the firm and is committed to fostering a collaborative and supportive work environment, where every team member can thrive and excel.

Allison Wetterau, Marketing/New Client Services Coordinator

Allison comes to the firm with a background in creative design and marketing strategy that has led to developing impactful community involvement campaigns, showcasing her commitment to leveraging creative strategy for meaningful engagement. Allison places the client experience at the forefront of all her initiatives, finding joy in nurturing both personal and professional relationships and contributing to her local community.

Hailey Murphy, Intake Specialist

Hailey is a Missouri native and new Florida resident with a strong background in bail bonds and notary public services. Driven by a deep passion for helping others through challenging times, Hailey brings a compassionate, client-focused approach to every case. Currently pursuing her Paralegal degree at Keiser University, she is committed to expanding her legal knowledge and continuing to serve her community with integrity and care.

Ashley Johnson, Data Operations Specialist

 

Ashley’s journey with Andrew Pickett Law began with a passion for connecting with people. With her unwavering commitment and extensive experience in client relations, Ashley plays a pivotal role in our team, ensuring that every potential new client receives the attention and care they deserve. Ashley’s empathetic approach and deep understanding of the process allows her to guide our clients seamlessly through the intake process, making their experience with us both informative and enjoyable.

 

Candace Piccirillo, Executive Assistant to Andrew Pickett

Candace Piccirillo is the Executive Assistant to Andrew Pickett at Andrew Pickett Law. With over six years of experience as an Executive Assistant, Candace excels at streamlining operations, managing complex schedules, and providing top-tier administrative support. Her dedication to organization and efficiency ensures the firm operates seamlessly, allowing the team to focus on delivering exceptional results for clients. Candace takes pride in being a dependable resource and contributing to the firm’s commitment to excellence.